A couple from New Jersey, who were left with serious injuries after their Uber crashed, have been told they cannot sue the company because of the terms they accepted when using the app. Despite arguing that they had not understood they were forfeiting their right to sue, state judges ruled that the couple had clicked a "confirm" button multiple times agreeing to Uber's terms of use. The terms state that all claims must be resolved in arbitration, meaning the dispute is settled through a third party rather than in court.
Background
In a recent case in New Jersey, a couple who were injured in an Uber crash were denied the right to sue the company due to the terms of use they agreed to when using the app. The couple, identified as Michael and Danielle Simonetti, were rear-ended by an Uber driver in August 2019. They sustained serious injuries, including a broken pelvis for Michael and a herniated disc for Danielle.
The Simonettis filed a lawsuit against Uber, but the company argued that the couple had agreed to mandatory arbitration when they signed up for the service. Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution where an independent third party, known as an arbitrator, hears the case and makes a binding decision.
Court Ruling
The Superior Court of New Jersey ruled in favor of Uber, finding that the Simonettis had "knowingly and voluntarily" agreed to mandatory arbitration by clicking a "confirm" button multiple times when they created their Uber account. The court also dismissed the couple's argument that they had not understood that they were forfeiting their right to sue by agreeing to arbitration.
Implications
The ruling has raised concerns among consumer advocates, who argue that mandatory arbitration clauses in consumer contracts can prevent victims of accidents from seeking justice in court. Arbitration proceedings are often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
Top 5 FAQs on Mandatory Arbitration in Uber Contracts
1. What is mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration is a process where disputes are settled through a third party, known as an arbitrator, rather than in court.
2. Why do companies like Uber use mandatory arbitration clauses?
Companies argue that mandatory arbitration clauses save time and money compared to lengthy court battles. They also claim that arbitration preserves the privacy of both parties involved.
3. What are the disadvantages of mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration clauses can prevent victims from seeking justice in court, where they have the right to a jury trial and the ability to appeal decisions. Arbitration proceedings are also often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
4. Can I opt out of mandatory arbitration with Uber?
No. The Uber terms of use do not allow riders to opt out of mandatory arbitration.
5. What should I do if I have been injured in an Uber accident?
If you have been injured in an Uber accident, it is important to seek medical attention and contact a personal injury attorney immediately. An attorney can help you understand your rights and options and can advise you on whether to pursue arbitration or file a lawsuit.
In an effort to reduce reliance on China for key minerals used in advanced technologies, India is exploring partnership with a rebel group in Myanmar to secure rare earth samples. The Ministry of Mines has directed state-owned and private companies to collect samples from Kachin Independence Army-controlled mines and test them in domestic labs. This move comes in light of China's recent export restrictions on rare earth magnets, causing disruptions in global supply chains.
Oracle chairman Larry Ellison, who hails from the Bronx, has surpassed Tesla CEO Elon Musk as the richest person in the world with a net worth of $405 billion. This jump in wealth was reported by Barron's on Wednesday, putting Ellison ahead of Musk's net worth of $390 billion. This milestone marks a shift in the top spot amongst the world's wealthiest individuals.
The US Producer Price Index fell 0.1% in August, bucking expectations of a rise and indicating a potential slowdown in overall economic growth. The decline was driven by a slump in the cost of services, particularly within wholesalers and retailers. The news has led to a drop in Treasury yields and solidifies expectations of an interest rate cut by the Federal Reserve next week.
The Hilton Kathmandu, once a symbol of Nepal's ambition and modern design, recently fell victim to violent anti-government protests. The hotel, built by the Shanker Group with a significant investment and featuring luxurious amenities and seismic safeguards, opened in 2024 but tragically, went up in flames a year later. The Hilton was not just a hotel, but a cultural statement, embodying Nepalese heritage and offering breathtaking views of the Langtang range.
In a shocking incident, a brand-new Mahindra Thar crashed through a glass wall and landed on the road below in Delhi's Preet Vihar. The SUV had just been purchased by a couple who were inside the vehicle at the time with a showroom salesman. Fortunately, no one was seriously injured in the accident. The incident, captured on video, has gone viral on social media. Police are investigating the cause of the incident.
Delhi-based manufacturer Vikas Ecotech has acquired an existing Plasticizer Manufacturing Business, valued at Rs 270 million, in an all-cash deal. With this acquisition, the company aims to enhance its product offering and become debt-free by 2023-24. This move comes after the firm recently paid off Rs 101 crore of its debt to lenders.
The Indian Express has obtained information that the Registrar General of India has requested a budget of Rs 14,618.95 crore for the upcoming Census 2027. This will be the first "digital census" and will include the collection of caste data through dedicated mobile applications. The option for self-enumeration will also be provided to the public. Additionally, Indian refiners have saved approximately $12.6 billion in the past three years through their Russian oil imports, which has caused tensions with the Trump administration.
The Trump administration's latest move has caused major disruptions in the Indian export industry with the imposition of 50% tariffs on Indian goods. Sectors such as apparel, textiles, gems, and jewelry will bear the brunt of the higher tariffs, putting low-skilled jobs in India at risk. India's response has been to extend tariff exemptions on cotton imports, but many are criticizing the government for not taking strong action against the US. Political figures like Saurabh Bhardwaj and Akhilesh Yadav have slammed the BJP-led government for its failed foreign and economic policies which are negatively impacting traders, manufacturers, and workers.
The highly anticipated 2025 model of the popular Suzuki Access 125 has finally been unveiled at the Auto Expo. While it comes in three variants and boasts 5 different colour options, there are complaints about the fluctuating mileage and poor design choices such as fixed mirrors. With tough competition in the two-wheeler market, Suzuki may need to offer attractive deals to customers to stay ahead.
At the Plumbex India exhibition, Minister Hardeep S Puri launched the BHARAT TAP initiative, which aims to improve products and services related to plumbing, water, and sanitation. In his speech, Puri emphasized the importance of sanitation in India's development and praised the success of the Swachh Bharat Mission and AMRUT in achieving 100% toilet coverage in rural areas and significant progress in urban areas. He also announced the launch of AMRUT 2.0, with an outlay of Rs. 2,77,000 crores, to further strengthen water and sanitation services in cities.