A couple from New Jersey, who were left with serious injuries after their Uber crashed, have been told they cannot sue the company because of the terms they accepted when using the app. Despite arguing that they had not understood they were forfeiting their right to sue, state judges ruled that the couple had clicked a "confirm" button multiple times agreeing to Uber's terms of use. The terms state that all claims must be resolved in arbitration, meaning the dispute is settled through a third party rather than in court.
Background
In a recent case in New Jersey, a couple who were injured in an Uber crash were denied the right to sue the company due to the terms of use they agreed to when using the app. The couple, identified as Michael and Danielle Simonetti, were rear-ended by an Uber driver in August 2019. They sustained serious injuries, including a broken pelvis for Michael and a herniated disc for Danielle.
The Simonettis filed a lawsuit against Uber, but the company argued that the couple had agreed to mandatory arbitration when they signed up for the service. Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution where an independent third party, known as an arbitrator, hears the case and makes a binding decision.
Court Ruling
The Superior Court of New Jersey ruled in favor of Uber, finding that the Simonettis had "knowingly and voluntarily" agreed to mandatory arbitration by clicking a "confirm" button multiple times when they created their Uber account. The court also dismissed the couple's argument that they had not understood that they were forfeiting their right to sue by agreeing to arbitration.
Implications
The ruling has raised concerns among consumer advocates, who argue that mandatory arbitration clauses in consumer contracts can prevent victims of accidents from seeking justice in court. Arbitration proceedings are often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
Top 5 FAQs on Mandatory Arbitration in Uber Contracts
1. What is mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration is a process where disputes are settled through a third party, known as an arbitrator, rather than in court.
2. Why do companies like Uber use mandatory arbitration clauses?
Companies argue that mandatory arbitration clauses save time and money compared to lengthy court battles. They also claim that arbitration preserves the privacy of both parties involved.
3. What are the disadvantages of mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration clauses can prevent victims from seeking justice in court, where they have the right to a jury trial and the ability to appeal decisions. Arbitration proceedings are also often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
4. Can I opt out of mandatory arbitration with Uber?
No. The Uber terms of use do not allow riders to opt out of mandatory arbitration.
5. What should I do if I have been injured in an Uber accident?
If you have been injured in an Uber accident, it is important to seek medical attention and contact a personal injury attorney immediately. An attorney can help you understand your rights and options and can advise you on whether to pursue arbitration or file a lawsuit.
Tesla, a leading electric vehicle (EV) company, has finally announced its foray into the Indian market with its first showroom opening in Mumbai this month. The company faced several delays due to import taxes and regulatory hurdles, but is now set to launch its first Experience Centre at the Bandra Kurla Complex. Tesla plans to offer six models in India with varying prices, starting from $40,000 and going up to $46,000. The company also plans to expand to Delhi and Bengaluru in the coming months, amidst new government rules aimed at boosting the production of electric cars in the country.
The highly anticipated Amazon Prime Day Sale is now live, offering some of the best deals on smartphones, electronics, and more. Popular brands like Samsung, OnePlus and Apple are offering attractive discounts on select models. Don't miss out on the opportunity to grab the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, Apple iPhone 16e, OnePlus 13, and iPhone 15 at discounted prices.
New research has shown the use of artificial intelligence can create a highly productive and respectful performance review conversation between managers and employees. In contrast to the traditional approach, Samvāda 2.0 encourages managers to use communicative GenAI tools, like ChatGPT or Copilot, to get prepared for a critical PRM session. This new and improved method ensures a mutual understanding, collaboration, and trust between the manager and employee, leading to more effective performance reviews.
The much-anticipated Amazon Prime Day Sale has officially begun, offering early deals until July 14. As an exclusive event for Prime members, this sale boasts discounts on popular electronics, including smartphones, smart TVs, air conditioners, and laptops from top brands like OnePlus, Samsung, iQOO, and more. With savings reaching up to 80%, it's a must-visit for tech enthusiasts and online shoppers alike.
In a major move for the Ambani family's succession plan, Anant Ambani has been promoted to Executive Director at Reliance Industries Ltd with a salary between ₹10 crore and ₹20 crore per year, plus a profit-linked commission and executive perks. Anant, who has been with the Reliance Group since 2015, will be in charge of the energy business and capital projects, including the company's foray into new energy sources.
Amazon Business has released a statement declaring their exciting deals for Prime Day 2025, which will take place from 12th to 14th July. This year's celebration will be the longest one yet- lasting for 72 hours! Customers can expect jaw-dropping discounts on a variety of products, so mark your calendars and get ready for some major shopping.
Zivame's latest campaign encourages women to break out of their comfort zones and embrace their inner desires with confidence, by providing them with intimate wear that is tailored to their body type and personal style. The campaign features women from different backgrounds and ages, showcasing how the right intimate wear can boost their body confidence and allow them to pursue their dreams without hesitation. With the tagline "Dekho Maine Kya Kiya," the campaign celebrates the freedom and joy that comes with embracing one's desires and showcasing them to the world.
Petroleum and Natural Gas Minister Hardeep Puri has silenced critics who questioned India's continued crude oil imports from Russia during their ongoing war with Ukraine. Puri explained that halting oil trade with Russia would have led to a 10% reduction in global oil supply, causing chaos and driving prices to over USD 120-130 per barrel. He also added that India, under the leadership of PM Modi, has been a positive contributor to global energy price stability while navigating the trilemma of energy availability, affordability, and sustainability.
Contact Energy, a New Zealand utility company, has successfully acquired Manawa Energy in a deal valued at over $200 million. This acquisition will result in Infratil, a major shareholder of Manawa, now owning a 9.5% stake in Contact Energy. The completion of the deal also brings changes to Manawa's board of directors, with four new directors from Contact joining and Manawa's previous chair, Deion Campbell, now sitting on Contact's board. The acquisition was first announced in September 2024 and has received necessary approvals before being finalized in June 2025.
Indian equity markets started off on a weak note on July 11 as Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) reported disappointing Q1 results. This resulted in a sharp decline in TCS shares, dragging down the broader IT sector. As a result, the BSE Sensex fell by 331 points and the Nifty50 also slipped by 68 points. In the broader market, the Nifty MidCap and SmallCap indices also witnessed losses. However, the Nifty Pharma and PSU Bank indices offered some support with gains. Meanwhile, global markets were mixed following US President Donald Trump's announcement of tariffs on Canadian goods and his plans for further tariffs. Despite this, US markets closed at record highs.