A couple from New Jersey, who were left with serious injuries after their Uber crashed, have been told they cannot sue the company because of the terms they accepted when using the app. Despite arguing that they had not understood they were forfeiting their right to sue, state judges ruled that the couple had clicked a "confirm" button multiple times agreeing to Uber's terms of use. The terms state that all claims must be resolved in arbitration, meaning the dispute is settled through a third party rather than in court.
Background
In a recent case in New Jersey, a couple who were injured in an Uber crash were denied the right to sue the company due to the terms of use they agreed to when using the app. The couple, identified as Michael and Danielle Simonetti, were rear-ended by an Uber driver in August 2019. They sustained serious injuries, including a broken pelvis for Michael and a herniated disc for Danielle.
The Simonettis filed a lawsuit against Uber, but the company argued that the couple had agreed to mandatory arbitration when they signed up for the service. Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution where an independent third party, known as an arbitrator, hears the case and makes a binding decision.
Court Ruling
The Superior Court of New Jersey ruled in favor of Uber, finding that the Simonettis had "knowingly and voluntarily" agreed to mandatory arbitration by clicking a "confirm" button multiple times when they created their Uber account. The court also dismissed the couple's argument that they had not understood that they were forfeiting their right to sue by agreeing to arbitration.
Implications
The ruling has raised concerns among consumer advocates, who argue that mandatory arbitration clauses in consumer contracts can prevent victims of accidents from seeking justice in court. Arbitration proceedings are often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
Top 5 FAQs on Mandatory Arbitration in Uber Contracts
1. What is mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration is a process where disputes are settled through a third party, known as an arbitrator, rather than in court.
2. Why do companies like Uber use mandatory arbitration clauses?
Companies argue that mandatory arbitration clauses save time and money compared to lengthy court battles. They also claim that arbitration preserves the privacy of both parties involved.
3. What are the disadvantages of mandatory arbitration?
Mandatory arbitration clauses can prevent victims from seeking justice in court, where they have the right to a jury trial and the ability to appeal decisions. Arbitration proceedings are also often held in secret, and the decisions made by arbitrators are not subject to judicial review.
4. Can I opt out of mandatory arbitration with Uber?
No. The Uber terms of use do not allow riders to opt out of mandatory arbitration.
5. What should I do if I have been injured in an Uber accident?
If you have been injured in an Uber accident, it is important to seek medical attention and contact a personal injury attorney immediately. An attorney can help you understand your rights and options and can advise you on whether to pursue arbitration or file a lawsuit.
The Indian stock market started the day on a negative note, with the Sensex and Nifty both opening in the red. This was due to weak global cues, with the BSE Sensex shedding 160.86 points and the Nifty falling 75.9 points in early trading. However, some stocks showed positive performance, with Eternal leading the pack. Meanwhile, Nifty 50's early indicator Gift Nifty indicated a positive start for the day. The previous day, Foreign Institutional Investors were net sellers while Domestic Institutional Investors bought equities.
The Telangana Southern Power Distribution Company Limited (TGSPDCL) has introduced "Currentolla Praja Baata" in Nalgonda, Medak, Mahabubnagar, Ranga Reddy, and Hyderabad, aimed at enhancing power distribution in the region. Led by CMD Musharraf Faruqui, the initiative will involve over 9,500 employees who will personally visit different areas to interact with consumers and address complaints. This program hopes to minimize power losses, strengthen the network, and improve the quality and reliability of power supply in Telangana.
A new Randstad India report reveals insights about India's youngest workforce cohort and their expectations for their careers. Gen Z prioritizes financial security, flexibility, and a sense of purpose in their job, requiring employers to go beyond just providing a decent salary. With a preference for a combination of a full-time job and a side hustle, Gen Z's mobility is driven by the pursuit of growth, making it crucial for employers to invest in continuous learning and foster inclusive cultures to retain this transformative generation.
According to Randstad India's latest report, young professionals in India are redefining workplace norms by prioritizing factors like pay, flexibility, and personal values. The report also reveals that Gen Z values continuous learning through AI tools and is more concerned about the impact of AI on job security. This calls for businesses to adapt to changing preferences and attract the next generation of talent by offering a mix of technical excellence and personal autonomy. The findings also emphasize the need for inclusive cultures and flexible policies in order to build resilient, future-ready businesses.
With the Gen-Z workforce making up about 27% of India's population, companies are struggling to retain this energetic cohort. A recent report by Randstad highlights the need for a change in mindset from employers towards the Gen-Zs. While they have long-term aspirations, they are also quick to move on to new opportunities if they feel undervalued or underpaid. This poses a challenge for employers who must find ways to keep this ambitious and driven generation engaged and progressing within their organizations.
Union Home Minister and Minister of Cooperation, Amit Shah, congratulated Amul and Indian Farmers Fertiliser Cooperative Limited (IFFCO) for securing the first and second ranks in the global ranking for cooperatives. This achievement is a testament to the boundless potential of cooperatives, which are being transformed into a global model of empowerment and self-reliance by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The dairy sector, which is the backbone of rural livelihoods in India, has combined farmer-led cooperatives, women's participation and scientific practices to achieve remarkable progress. Additionally, the National Co-operative Exports Limited, set up by the government, has achieved a significant milestone in exporting agricultural commodities.
After purchasing his retirement property in Swansea, David Barlow has been forced to live in a motorhome on his driveway due to persistent damp and mould issues. Despite complaints to his property managers, the issue has not been resolved and Barlow fears for his belongings. The problem is believed to have been caused by faulty insulation installed by British Gas, but the company denies responsibility. This situation has put a hold on Barlow's retirement plans and has left him feeling frustrated and stuck.
US-based private equity firm Tillman Global Holdings (TGH) is reportedly in advanced discussions to invest up to $6 billion in Vodafone Idea Ltd, which could lead to a change in operational control. However, the investment is contingent on the Indian government providing comprehensive relief covering AGR and spectrum payment dues. If the deal goes through, it could dilute existing promoter holdings, including those held by Aditya Birla Group and Vodafone Plc. While the news has boosted investor sentiment, analysts caution that government approval and debt restructuring clarity are key to the execution of the deal.
The Indian real estate market is undergoing a major shift with rising home prices, as apartments priced between Rs 2 crore and Rs 5 crore now dominate sales. This change has been highlighted by a Redditor who expressed concerns over the dwindling chances of middle-class buyers to afford a house. According to a Moneycontrol report, the trend is a result of big developers focusing more on luxury projects, leaving affordable housing in the backseat. As a result, home ownership for the middle-class seems like a distant dream, with even government employees struggling to afford these expensive properties.
Vodafone Idea's share price saw a significant increase of 14% after the Supreme Court provided further clarity on the AGR dues issue. The court clarified that the government can consider providing relief for both additional and reassessed AGR dues, giving some respite to the struggling telecom operator. At the time of writing, Vodafone Idea's share price was trading at Rs 9.51, with a gain of 8.93%. This comes after the court's previous hearing which did not provide a clear ruling on whether the relief applies to only Vodafone Idea's plea or the entire pending AGR amount of nearly Rs 80,000 crore.