This article explores the historical origins of club culture in India, particularly in Calcutta during colonial times. It compares the culture of messes, which were primarily for upper-caste, male students, to the contemporary club and gymkhana culture in India. The recent controversy surrounding cricketer Jemimah Rodrigues and her father's alleged "conversion" activities at a Mumbai gymkhana highlights the powerful role these institutions play in determining social hierarchies and notions of respectability. Ultimately, club membership is not just about access to amenities, but also about subscribing to certain societal norms and values.
Jemimah Rodrigues and the Khar Gymkhana: A Tale of Social Exclusion
Background
Club culture in India has deep-rooted historical origins, particularly in the city of Calcutta during colonial times. The establishment of exclusive clubs and gymkhanas was initially limited to upper-caste, male students. These institutions served as spaces for socializing, recreation, and networking.
In contemporary India, clubs and gymkhanas continue to play a significant role in determining social hierarchies and notions of respectability. They offer exclusive amenities and services, often catering to the elite and affluent.
The Jemimah Rodrigues Incident
In 2022, cricketer Jemimah Rodrigues faced controversy when she and her father were allegedly asked to leave the Khar Gymkhana in Mumbai. The alleged reason was that her father was conducting "conversion" activities, which were perceived as violative of the club's norms.
The incident sparked outrage and debate, highlighting the deep-seated biases and discriminatory practices that persist within certain social institutions in India.
FAQs
1. Why was Jemimah Rodrigues asked to leave the Khar Gymkhana? Allegedly, her father was conducting "conversion" activities, which were seen as violating the club's norms.
2. What do these institutions represent? Club culture in India often represents social hierarchies and notions of respectability, with exclusive membership being a symbol of status and privilege.
3. What are the historical roots of club culture in India? Club culture in India has its origins in the colonial era, when exclusive clubs and gymkhanas were established for upper-caste, male students.
4. How has club culture evolved in contemporary India? Contemporary clubs and gymkhanas continue to cater to the elite and affluent, offering exclusive amenities and services. However, they also face scrutiny for their exclusionary practices.
5. What are the implications of the Jemimah Rodrigues incident for Indian society? The incident highlights the prevalence of deep-seated biases and discriminatory practices within certain social institutions in India. It also raises questions about the need for inclusivity and equality in all aspects of society.
Congress MP Rahul Gandhi calls out the government's 'monopoly model' as responsible for IndiGo's crisis of cancelling hundreds of flights. Emphasizing the need for fair competition in all sectors, Gandhi highlights the impact on ordinary Indians who bear the brunt of delays, cancellations, and helplessness. Amid IndiGo seeking relaxation from new regulations, the Civil Aviation Minister has warned the airline to normalize its operations at the earliest.
Melania Trump, the First Lady of the United States, has revealed the Christmas decorations at the White House, focusing on American values of generosity and patriotism. She thanked the volunteers who tirelessly decorated the mansion and emphasized the message of "Home Is Where the Heart Is". The theme of this year's celebrations is a reflection of Trump's busy life as both a mother and a businesswoman. She wants to spread the message of love and grace during this holiday season.
During an exhibit at the World Trade Centre, Maharashtra BJP Minister Mangal Prabhat Lodha praised Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, stating that he not only runs the BJP but also controls other political outfits in the state. Shiv Sena MLA Sanjay Gaikwad disputed this claim, stating that their party is solely controlled by Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde. A political observer noted the rising trend of sycophancy and cult personalities in the BJP and their eagerness to demonstrate their closeness to Fadnavis.
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor introduced a Private Member’s Bill to amend the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and remove the marital rape exception, reaffirming that marriage cannot negate a woman's right to grant or deny consent. Tharoor argues that the criminalization of marital rape is an urgent necessity in India's legal system and stresses the importance of upholding constitutional values and adopting a consent standard that leaves no room for ambiguity. He emphasizes that the issue is about violence, not marriage, and asserts that all women deserve the fundamental right to bodily autonomy and dignity.
Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis emphasized the need for equality beyond traditional social reservations in his interaction with orphaned young people who secured government jobs through the 1 per cent orphan reservation policy. He made this statement at his official residence in Mumbai, Varsha, while discussing the need for inclusivity and equal opportunities for all citizens. Fadnavis stressed that discrimination should not exist in any form and that all individuals should have equal opportunities to succeed.
As Prime Minister Narendra Modi marks the first anniversary of his government, opinions are divided on the performance of the BJP-led NDA government. However, global institutions and investors have shown increasing confidence in the Indian economy over the past year. Despite this, there are still important issues that need to be addressed by the Prime Minister in order to continue the successful trajectory of the country.
Union Home Minister Amit Shah spoke at the inauguration of the 60th DGsP/IGsP conference in Raipur where he stated that Naxalism in India will be fully eliminated before the next conference. He also highlighted the government's efforts in strengthening the security grid and providing permanent solutions to long-standing national security challenges. Shah emphasized the importance of intelligence and collaboration with agencies to tackle drug trafficking and organized crime. He also mentioned the strengthening of India's policing framework, making it amongst the most modern globally.
In a recent Q&A session, Professor Michael Clarke addressed the impact of a leaked call between Donald Trump's envoy and Russia on peace talks. He also discussed Putin's desire for a great legacy, which has led to a lack of pragmatism. According to Clarke, approximately 4,000 main battle tanks and 30,000 pieces of armoured equipment have been destroyed in the conflict, with Russia focusing on building more complex modern tanks. Don't miss out on these insightful answers from the expert.
Following his party's disappointing performance in the recent Bihar Assembly election, politician Prashant Kishor has raised concerns about the voting results, stating that they did not align with the public sentiment he witnessed during his campaign. Despite this setback, Kishor remains determined to build a stronger political organization and continue engaging with the public in preparation for future elections. He also addressed criticisms of his role as an election strategist, reminding critics that one loss does not define his political future.
Indian government under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has introduced four new labour codes aimed at protecting the rights and well-being of 40 crore workers across the country. Union Minister Mansukh Mandaviya has hailed the move as transformative and a major step towards ensuring the welfare of the workforce. The new codes bring in much-needed changes such as formalisation and transparency through appointment letters, and universal social security coverage for all workers including gig and platform workers.