logo
India vs Australia

Rohit Sharma's Absence from Fifth Test Raises Questions about Indian Cricket Culture

January 3, 2025 at 10:24:51 AM GMT+5:30

Former India star Sanjay Manjrekar questions why Rohit Sharma's decision to opt out of the fifth Test against Australia was not thoroughly discussed at the toss, highlighting a larger issue with the secretive nature of Indian cricket. Despite stand-in captain Jasprit Bumrah's statement about Sharma's rest being a show of unity, Manjrekar raises doubts about the legitimacy of the absence and the importance of transparency for fans.

Know More

India vs Australia: Rohit Sharma's Absence from Fifth Test Raises Questions

The decision by Indian captain Rohit Sharma to opt out of the fifth and final Test against Australia has raised questions about the team's transparency and unity. Former India star Sanjay Manjrekar has criticized the lack of discussion surrounding Sharma's absence at the toss, highlighting a larger issue with the secretive nature of Indian cricket.

Sharma, who was initially expected to lead India in the fifth Test, cited a hamstring injury as the reason for his withdrawal. However, Manjrekar suggests that there may have been more to his decision than meets the eye.

Lack of Discussion at Toss

"Why was Rohit Sharma's decision not to play the fifth Test not discussed at the toss?" Manjrekar asked in a column for ESPNcricinfo. "I would have thought this was the most important aspect of the morning, a moment to show unity and transparency."

Manjrekar pointed out that the Indian team management has a history of making decisions behind closed doors, which has led to speculation and rumors. He believes that the lack of open discussion about Sharma's absence sent the wrong message to fans.

Doubt over Legitimacy of Absence

Manjrekar also questioned the legitimacy of Sharma's injury claim. He noted that Sharma was seen batting in the nets just days before the match and that there were no signs of any discomfort.

"I'm not saying Sharma is not injured," Manjrekar wrote. "But I am saying that the optics of it all are not good. There is a need for transparency and accountability in Indian cricket."

Importance of Transparency

Manjrekar emphasized the importance of transparency for Indian cricket fans. He argued that they have a right to know why their captain is not playing in a crucial Test match.

"The fans deserve to know the truth," Manjrekar said. "They are the ones who support the team through thick and thin. They deserve honesty and respect."

Top 5 FAQs and Answers

  1. Why did Rohit Sharma opt out of the fifth Test?

Sharma cited a hamstring injury as the reason for his withdrawal.

  1. Why was Sharma's absence not discussed at the toss?

The Indian team management did not provide a clear explanation.

  1. Is there doubt over the legitimacy of Sharma's injury?

Some experts have suggested that there may be more to his decision than meets the eye.

  1. What is Sanjay Manjrekar's criticism?

Manjrekar has criticized the lack of transparency surrounding Sharma's absence and the secretive nature of Indian cricket.

  1. Why is transparency important in Indian cricket?

Fans have a right to know why their captain is not playing in a crucial Test match, and it promotes accountability and unity within the team.

Relevant News
Columbus
October 14, 2025 at 02:03:04 AM GMT+5:30

Despite being rained out for the first time in its 81-year history, the Columbus Day Parade celebrated the spirit of Italian heritage this year with football legend Joe Moglia as its grand marshal. Moglia, who was ecstatic to receive the honor, proudly represented his hometown of NYC and his Italian roots. Despite the cancellation, the other events of the weekend, including a mass led by Cardinal Dolan, will remain a highlight of Moglia's life. The former CEO and Chairman of TD Ameritrade turned Coastal Carolina University football coach, Moglia's success and accomplishments continue to inspire and garner respect.

Punk
October 14, 2025 at 02:02:46 AM GMT+5:30

Former WWE superstar CM Punk made a triumphant return to the ring at today's "WWE Raw" event in Australia. After a hard-fought match, Punk emerged as the new number-one contender for the World Heavyweight Championship, but his next match may be in jeopardy due to current champion Seth Rollins' injury. Despite this, Punk expressed his love for the rowdy crowd in Perth and his excitement for future matches.

Bron
October 14, 2025 at 02:02:37 AM GMT+5:30

Up-and-coming wrestler Bron Breakker made a bold move at the end of WWE Raw by forming a new faction called "The Vision," with fellow wrestlers Bronson Reed and Paul Heyman by his side. The trio took out superstar Seth Rollins in a stunning turn of events, leaving fans on social media buzzing with excitement. This unexpected alliance promises to bring a new dynamic to the WWE and could shake up the wrestling world in the coming matches. Stay tuned for more updates on "The Vision's" journey to the top.

God Night Monday
October 14, 2025 at 12:02:33 AM GMT+5:30

As the NFL season enters Week 6, fans are in for a treat with a Monday Night Football doubleheader featuring two exciting matchups. The explosive Falcons will take on the Bills, while the Commanders host the Bears in a battle of top teams. Both games are expected to be high-scoring affairs, making them must-watch for football fans. Get ready for an action-packed evening of football with these thrilling Monday night showdowns.

Seth
October 13, 2025 at 09:38:10 PM GMT+5:30

In a high-stakes episode of Monday Night RAW, CM Punk emerged as the No. 1 contender for the World Heavyweight Championship after a thrilling triple threat match against LA Knight and Jey Uso. But as Punk celebrated his victory, his own ally, Bron Breakker, betrayed him with a thunderous spear, signaling the end of Seth Rollins' powerful faction, The Vision. With this shocking turn of events, the main event scene in WWE RAW is set for a seismic shift as Punk is now set to challenge Rollins for the title.

Undeserving Arjun
October 13, 2025 at 09:38:00 PM GMT+5:30

Arjun Tendulkar, the son of cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar, recently made headlines with news of his engagement to Saaniya Chandhok, the granddaughter of industrialist Ravi Ghai. Despite not having played for India yet, Arjun has already established himself in domestic cricket and has earned around Rs 1.2 crore from his IPL appearances and Rs 10 lakh per year from domestic cricket. In addition, he has also played grade-level cricket in England. With a lavish bungalow in Bandra and a net worth estimated at Rs 22 crore, Arjun's success is a testament to his talent and hard work.

West  Indies
October 13, 2025 at 05:38:41 PM GMT+5:30

After a 51-year wait, two West Indies batters have scored centuries in the second innings of a Test match in India, with John Campbell and Shai Hope leading the charge in the Delhi Test. Campbell and Hope ended their own long wait for three-figure marks, with Campbell scoring his maiden Test hundred after 49 innings and Hope hitting only his third century after a gap of 58 innings. The two also put up a crucial 177-run partnership for the third wicket, frustrating the Indian bowlers on a slow and low surface.

John  Campbell
October 13, 2025 at 12:38:12 PM GMT+5:30

West Indies opener John Campbell scored his maiden Test century in a gritty performance against India in the second Test at the Arun Jaitley Stadium. With this century, Campbell joined legendary players Viv Richards and Kapil Dev in an exclusive list of batsmen who have scored their first Test century in Delhi. He also became the 17th cricketer overall and the sixth West Indian to achieve this feat. His century came in his 48th innings, making him the second slowest opener to reach this milestone in Test cricket. The last opener to take longer was South Africa's Trevor Goddard.

Healy
October 13, 2025 at 08:38:12 AM GMT+5:30

Australian cricketer Alyssa Healy's aggressive batting was the key factor in her team's victory against India at the 2025 World Cup. Despite facing personal rivalry and struggling with her batting rhythm, Healy rose to the occasion and took down India's weakened bowling attack. Her calculated assault and unbeaten century helped extend Australia's unbeaten run in World Cups to 12 games and shattered records. Healy's impressive performance proved why she is considered a big-match player and cemented her position as a top player in international cricket.

Sneh  Rana
October 13, 2025 at 12:38:40 AM GMT+5:30

All-rounder Sneh Rana of the defending Women's World Cup team India showed confidence in the team's ability to rise above their recent defeat and challenge seven-time champions Australia in their upcoming match. Rana acknowledged their tough opponent but assured that the team has regrouped and planned carefully to capture victory. Despite a slower start from their top-order batters, Rana expressed trust in their skills and determination to bounce back. The team is working on improving key aspects, such as strike rotation, and is determined to come out strong in their next game.