The fifth Test match between Australia and India at the Sydney Cricket Ground was off to an intense start as the Australian team thought they had caught star batsman Virat Kohli out on the first ball. However, third umpire Joel Wilson gave it not out, causing a stir among former Australian players and coaches. While Justin Langer and Ricky Ponting believe Kohli should have been given out, the decision has divided opinions and sparked a heated debate.
Umpire Joel Wilson's Controversial Decision Divides Cricket World
Background
During the fifth Test match between Australia and India at the Sydney Cricket Ground in 2021, umpire Joel Wilson sparked controversy with a not-out decision involving star batsman Virat Kohli on the first ball of the match. The Australian team believed Kohli had been caught out by wicketkeeper Tim Paine, but Wilson overturned the decision based on a review using the Decision Review System (DRS).
Wilson's Decision and Its Impact
Wilson's decision was met with mixed reactions. Australian former players and coaches, such as Justin Langer and Ricky Ponting, expressed their belief that Kohli should have been given out. Others, however, defended Wilson's decision, citing the lack of conclusive evidence to overturn the on-field umpire's call.
The incident sparked a heated debate about the use of DRS and the role of umpires in the game of cricket. Some argued that the technology was being used excessively, while others defended its use as a means of ensuring fair play.
Top 5 FAQs and Answers
1. Why was Joel Wilson's decision controversial?
Wilson overturned an on-field decision of out, sparking a debate about the use of DRS and the role of umpires.
2. What were the opinions of former Australian players and coaches?
Langer and Ponting believed Kohli should have been given out, while others defended Wilson's decision.
3. How did the incident impact the match?
Kohli went on to score a century in India's first innings, which put the visitors in a strong position.
4. What is the role of DRS in cricket?
DRS is a technology that allows umpires to review decisions made on the field. It involves the use of replays and ball-tracking software.
5. Has Joel Wilson been involved in other controversial decisions?
Wilson has been involved in other controversial decisions throughout his career, including a no-ball call in the 2019 Cricket World Cup that ultimately cost Australia a place in the final.
Conclusion
Joel Wilson's not-out decision in the fifth Test between Australia and India remains a talking point in the cricket world. The incident highlighted the complexities of using technology in the game and the challenges faced by umpires in making split-second decisions. While the debate surrounding Wilson's decision is likely to continue, it has also shed light on the importance of fair play and the role of technology in ensuring a level playing field.
Indian cricketer Prithvi Shaw showed his softer side by sharing an endearing message for social media influencer and actress Akriti Agarwal. The duo recently celebrated Ganesh Chaturthi together, giving fans a glimpse of their camaraderie. Despite facing a setback in the 2025 IPL auction, Shaw is determined to make a strong comeback with his new team and has been working hard to improve his batting skills, according to Maharashtra's chief selector Akshay Darekar.
With a chance to continue their winning streak, Manchester United head to the Etihad for a heated derby match against Manchester City. Despite City's recent struggles, United should not underestimate their rivals as both teams are vying for dominance in the Premier League. However, with last season's win at the Etihad and a confident Ruben Amorim at the helm, United are poised to secure another victory. Meanwhile, the speculation surrounding the future of Manchester United's manager continues, with names like Zinedine Zidane and Sean Dyche being thrown into the mix.
In a thrilling match at the Johan Cruyff Stadium, Spanish champions Barcelona put on a masterclass performance against Valencia. The highlight of the game was Marcus Rashford's top-notch assist for Barcelona's second goal, showing his potential as a loanee from Manchester United. With Raphinha and Robert Lewandowski also scoring and the use of VAR, it was a night to remember for Barcelona's fans.
After being sidelined for 383 days due to a major injury, FC Barcelona's Marc Bernal made a stunning comeback during the team's clash with Valencia. The 18-year-old was greeted by a standing ovation from his teammates and fans as he stepped onto the pitch. In just a few minutes, he made an impact by assisting in the team's 6-0 win. This comeback marks a major milestone in Bernal's journey as a player and he will be looking to continue building on this next step in his career.
In a thrilling and high stakes match, India proved their superiority over Pakistan, winning by seven wickets. However, the Indian team's decision to not shake hands with their opponents and captain Suryakumar Yadav's dedication of the win to the armed forces sparked controversy and questions. India's victory was aided by impressive performances from players like Kuldeep Yadav, Axar Patel, and Abhishek Sharma, who was hailed by Suryakumar as the player of the match. The win has secured India a spot in the Super 4s of the Asia Cup, making it a happy birthday for Suryakumar, who also achieved his personal goal of staying on the crease till the end. With the return of Sourav Ganguly as the President of the Cricket Association of Bengal, Indian cricket is looking to maintain its strong and successful legacy.
India's Kuldeep Yadav takes 3 wickets and Suryakumar Yadav dedicates win to Armed Forces at post-match presentation while Afridi's 36 runs not enough for Pakistan In a highly anticipated match between India and Pakistan in the Asia Cup, Pakistan's batting proved to be no match for India's spinners, with Kuldeep Yadav taking 3 wickets and restricting Pakistan to 127 runs. Suryakumar Yadav also shone with his statement dedicating the win to India's Armed Forces. In a dominant display, India easily chased the target in just 16 overs with a brilliant performance from Suryakumar and Afridi's cameo not enough for Pakistan.
The India vs Pakistan clash in the Asia Cup 2025 has been a controversial topic, with some calling for it to be cancelled following recent events. However, the Indian Supreme Court has given the green signal for the match to proceed, citing the new Sports Bill which allows for multi-team tournaments but restricts bilateral ties. The court also declined to list an urgent PIL seeking cancellation of the match.
India and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) are set to kick off their journey in the highly anticipated Asia Cup 2025 with a clash against each other. Led by Suryakumar Yadav, India is seen as one of the leading contenders for the title, with a strong batting unit and a well-rounded bowling attack. On the other hand, UAE, led by Muhammad Waseem, is the underdog in this match, but will aim to put up a tough fight in front of their home crowd. With live streaming and telecast details available, fans are eagerly waiting for the showdown between these two teams.
Ace pacer Jasprit Bumrah proved why he's considered one of the best bowlers in the world as he made a successful T20I comeback against UAE in the Asia Cup 2025. With a searing yorker, Bumrah knocked over opening batter Alishan Sharafu, giving his team an early breakthrough. However, former India captain Ajay Jadeja felt that the star bowler should have been rested for the match against a weaker UAE side. Although there are concerns about his workload, Bumrah continues to shine on the field.
In their opening game of the 2025 Asia Cup, India displayed a dominant performance against the UAE, winning by a staggering margin of 103 runs. Kuldeep Yadav's four-wicket haul and Suryakumar Yadav's captaincy and batting prowess led the team to victory. This marks India's first T20 match since February and the team showed no signs of rustiness, asserting their status as one of the top teams in the format.