The Supreme Court has made a historic decision to allow states to create sub-classifications within the Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) categories for the purposes of providing wider protections. This overturns the court's previous ruling in 2004 that the SC/ST list is a "homogeneous group" and cannot be further divided. The decision was reached in a 6:1 ruling, with five judges in favor of sub-classification and one in dissent. This ruling has implications for states and groups within the SC list that have been underrepresented, opening the door for more protection and opportunity.
Supreme Court Upholds States' Right to Sub-Classify Scheduled Castes and Tribes
Background
The Constitution of India recognizes Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) as socially and economically disadvantaged communities. To address their needs, the government provides them with reservations in education, employment, and other spheres.
In 2004, the Supreme Court ruled that the SC/ST list was a "homogeneous group" and could not be further divided. This meant that states could not create sub-classifications within these categories to provide targeted support to specific groups.
Historic Decision
On October 11, 2022, the Supreme Court overturned its previous ruling in a landmark 6:1 decision. The court upheld the validity of the 102nd Constitutional Amendment, which empowers states to create sub-classifications within the SC and ST categories.
In its judgment, the court held that the blanket homogenization of SCs and STs overlooked the vast diversity within these communities. The court recognized that certain groups within the SC and ST categories have been historically more marginalized than others.
Implications
The decision has significant implications for states and groups that have been underrepresented within the SC and ST categories. States can now create sub-classifications to provide specific benefits and protections to these underrepresented groups.
This decision is expected to lead to greater equality and opportunity for marginalized communities within the SC and ST categories. It is a step towards ensuring that the benefits of constitutional protections reach all members of these communities.
FAQs
1. What is the significance of the 102nd Constitutional Amendment? The 102nd Amendment empowers states to create sub-classifications within the SC and ST categories. This allows states to provide targeted support to groups that have been historically underrepresented.
2. What was the previous Supreme Court ruling on this issue? In 2004, the Supreme Court ruled that the SC/ST list was a "homogeneous group" and could not be further divided. This meant that states could not create sub-classifications.
3. What is the rationale behind the court's recent decision? The court recognized that there is significant diversity within the SC and ST categories. Certain groups within these categories have been historically more marginalized than others. By allowing sub-classifications, the court aims to address this inequality.
4. How will this decision impact states? States can now create sub-classifications to provide specific benefits and protections to underrepresented groups within the SC and ST categories. This will lead to greater equality and opportunity.
5. What are the expected benefits of this decision? The decision is expected to improve access to education, employment, and other opportunities for marginalized groups within the SC and ST categories. It is a step towards ensuring that the constitutional protections extended to these communities are effectively implemented.
Government officials in the UK are facing backlash from citizens as Storm Bram brings heavy rain and winds, leading to flood warnings and potential risks to life. Good Morning Britain presenters Richard Madeley and Susanna Reid raised concerns about the lack of warning to those living in affected areas, while viewers expressed frustration over inconsistent warning systems. With severe weather conditions expected to continue throughout the country, citizens are calling for better communication and preparation from their government.
A shocking conspiracy was uncovered by the Bihar Police when they arrested an individual from Bhojpur for allegedly issuing death threats to MP Pappu Yadav. The whole scheme was concocted by his close associates to garner enhanced security for Yadav. The arrested man, Ram Babu, has confessed to making a threatening video at the behest of the MP's associates, who had promised him a position in their party. Police are still investigating the instigator of this plot and are also looking into other aspects of the case.
Congress-led UDF emerged as the leading force in the Kerala local body elections, securing a majority in 505 out of 941 Grama Panchayats. Meanwhile, the BJP-led NDA made significant gains, winning the Thiruvananthapuram Corporation for the first time and retaining key municipalities. Union Home Minister Amit Shah credited the victories to PM Narendra Modi's leadership and vision for "Vikasita Keralam".
In a significant victory for the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), three women candidates secured seats in the Kerala local body elections. Former Mayor and MCD AAP Councillor Dr. Shelly Oberoi congratulated the winners, praising their success as a strong example of women's empowerment. Meanwhile, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge expressed his gratitude to the people of Kerala for giving a decisive verdict in favor of the United Democratic Front (UDF), while Prime Minister Narendra Modi acknowledged and praised the efforts of BJP workers in the state. This outcome reflects the increasing support for female leaders and potentially hints at a greater shift towards progressive politics in the state.
As the counting for the local body elections in Kerala began, the Congress-led UDF is in the lead in most of the city and town local bodies. This two-phase election, held on December 9 and 11, has seen a high voter turnout of over 70%. The results of this election will have a significant impact on the political landscape ahead of the 2026 Assembly elections in Kerala, with local body results often reflecting voter mood. Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge has expressed confidence in the UDF alliance's chances in the upcoming Assembly polls.
R Sreelekha, the former DGP and BJP's mayoral candidate in Thiruvananthapuram Corporation, secured a victory in the Sasthamangalam ward and pledges to deliver a corruption-free administration if given the chance to serve the public. Other notable victories in the corporation elections include former district president VV Rajesh and UDF mayoral candidate KS Sabarinathan. However, some high-profile defeats were seen, including actor Poojapura Radhakrishnan and Congress leader Johnson Joseph. Independent candidate Pattoor Radhakrishnan and Congress candidate Mary Pushpam also emerged victoriously in their respective wards.
According to sources, the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise in West Bengal has identified a total of 58,80,202 voters who may be excluded from the draft voter list. This includes people who have passed away, transferred, missing, and identified as 'fake' by the Election Commission. These numbers are subject to change in the final list, which is set to be published on February 14, 2022. The commission has divided voters into three categories - own mapping, progeny mapping, and non-mapping - depending on their presence in the 2002 voter list. Those not falling into any of these categories will be called for a hearing by the EC.
In a significant shift in voter sentiment, the Congress-led United Democratic Front (UDF) is set for a decisive win in the Kerala local body elections, dealing a major setback to the ruling CPM-led Left Democratic Front (LDF) ahead of the 2026 Assembly elections. The UDF has consolidated its gains across urban local bodies, while the LDF's last-minute welfare push failed to curb anti-incumbency. The NDA also made significant gains, underlining its expanding presence in urban Kerala.
In a major upset, the BJP-led NDA has won the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation, ending the CPI(M)-led LDF's 45-year reign. The victory, with the NDA winning 50 out of 101 seats, is a boost for BJP's aspirations in Kerala's upcoming Assembly elections. The party's strong focus on development and Hindutva in Thiruvananthapuram, under the leadership of state unit president Rajeev Chandrasekhar, proved successful despite challenges faced during the campaigning. This victory has put the BJP in a strong position for the 2021 Assembly elections.
The Bharatiya Janata Party-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) has taken a huge lead in Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation, giving a setback to the ruling Left Democratic Front (LDF). Initial trends show the NDA leading in 25 wards, while the LDF is ahead in 15 wards and the UDF in 10 wards. This is a major blow to the LDF ahead of the upcoming assembly elections in Kerala, with a record voter turnout of 73.69%. The State Election Commission has also commended the peaceful conduct of the elections.